New approaches and technical considerations in detecting outlier measurements and trajectories in longitudinal children growth data Full Text

Meaning, if a data point is found to be an outlier, it is removed from the data set and the test is applied again with a new average and rejection region. Outliers can occur by chance in any distribution, but they can indicate novel behaviour or structures in the data-set, measurement error, or that the population has a heavy-tailed distribution. A frequent cause of outliers is a mixture of two distributions, which may be two distinct sub-populations, or may indicate 'correct trial' versus 'measurement error'; this is modeled by a mixture model. In this article, we’ve covered the basic definition of an outlier, as well as its possible categorizations. Removing outliers solely due to their place in the extremes of your dataset may create inconsistencies in your results, which would be counterproductive to your goals as a data analyst. These inconsistencies may lead to reduced statistical significance in an analysis.

This is similar to the choice you’re faced with when dealing with missing data. Your outliers are any values greater than your upper fence or less than your lower fence. There aren't any values higher than 55 so this dataset doesn't have any outliers.

In the same way, the addition of 3.0 x IQR to the third quartile allows us to define strong outliers by looking at points which are greater than this number. Multiplying the interquartile range (IQR) by 1.5 will give us a way to determine whether a certain value is an outlier. If we subtract 1.5 x IQR from the first quartile, any data values that are less than this number are considered outliers. Similarly, if we add 1.5 x IQR to the third quartile, any data values that are greater than this number are considered outliers. Other outliers are problematic and should be removed because they represent measurement errors, data entry or processing errors, or poor sampling. It’s a tricky procedure because it’s often impossible to tell the two types apart for sure.

Impact of outlier detection methods on growth pattern analysis

An outlier is an observation that lies outside the overall pattern of a distribution (Moore and McCabe 1999). This can be a case which does not fit the model under study, or an error in measurement. Statisticians, who often attempt to mitigate the effect of outliers, have come up with ways to identify what makes an outlier.

  • The choice of how to deal with an outlier should depend on the cause.
  • Second, the fewer outliers found beyond a high SD threshold, the higher the chances that they will be outliers (true positives), implying increased precision.
  • Student answers will vary, but they should mention that not all outliers should be thrown away.
  • In most larger samplings of data, some data points will be further away from the sample mean than what is deemed reasonable.

If your dataset ends up containing many outliers, you may need to use a statistical test that’s more robust to them. Just like with missing values, the most conservative option is to keep outliers in your dataset. Keeping outliers is usually the better option when you’re not sure if they are errors. This method is helpful if you have a few values on the extreme ends of your dataset, but you aren’t sure whether any of them might count as outliers. You can convert extreme data points into z scores that tell you how many standard deviations away they are from the mean. True outliers are also present in variables with skewed distributions where many data points are spread far from the mean in one direction.

Origin of outlier

We examined if the applied combination improved the results of the individual methods. Outliers are data points that are unusual or extreme with the rest of the dataset. Outliers can arise for various reasons, such as measurement errors, data entry errors, or extreme values in the underlying population. There are several types of outliers, including univariate, multivariate, and influential, each with different characteristics and impacts on statistical analysis. We next tested the performance of combining outlier detection methods in three random simulations that included ALL errors.

Outlier detection methods (Table

These data values lie outside the overall trend, which already lies in the data. Outliers are extremely low or extremely high stragglers in a given set of data that can create an error in your stats. For instance, if one measured the length of a child’s nose, their common value might lie if Pinocchio implied in the given class of data values. The modified Thompson Tau test is used to find one outlier at a time (largest value of δ is removed if it is an outlier).

Step 4: Calculate your upper fence

To show these outliers, the Isolation Forest will build “Isolation Trees” from the set of data, and outliers will be shown as the points that have shorter average path lengths than the rest of the branches. In data analytics, analysts create data visualizations to present data graphically in a meaningful and impactful way, in order to present their findings to relevant stakeholders. These visualizations can easily show trends, patterns, and outliers from a large set of data in the form of maps, graphs and charts. When going through the process of data analysis, outliers can cause anomalies in the results obtained.

Read more articles

Finally, our sensitivity analyses showed that the SD threshold could also impact outlier method performance. First, the lower the threshold is, the more outliers will be detected by the method, as fewer measurements or trajectories entering invoices and receipts side by side in xero will remain close enough to the average to avoid detection. Second, the fewer outliers found beyond a high SD threshold, the higher the chances that they will be outliers (true positives), implying increased precision.

Even though visual assessment [16, 17] can be used to detect entire outlier trajectories, this approach is impractical when analyzing larger epidemiological datasets. A more practical approach to detect outlier trajectories is crucial because trajectories are essential tools for growth monitoring. We next studied the agreement between outlier detection approaches for measurements and trajectories.

Error density affected method performance in a similar manner as in the main analysis. We conducted two different sensitivity analyses; the first aimed to assess the impact of a different density of outliers. In our original experiments, synthetic outliers were randomly injected in 15% of the measurements, replacing the original measurements and resulting in one to two outlier data points for each child. For the first sensitivity analysis, we injected outliers in 30% of the children with four outliers each.

How to calculate Q1 in an even dataset

For example, when measuring blood pressure, your doctor likely has a good idea of what is considered to be within the normal blood pressure range. If they were looking at the values above, they would identify that all of the values that are highlighted orange indicate high blood pressure. There is not a hard and fast rule about how much a data point needs to differ to be considered an outlier.

A value is suspected to be a potential outlier if it is less than (1.5)(IQR) below the first quartile or more than (1.5)(IQR) above the third quartile. A study of teenagers’ time spent on social media over the course of a week could create an opportunity for positive deviance. If most teens spend a lot of time on social media, the outliers may be able to provide insights into alternative engagement opportunities for teens. When performing least squares fitting to data, it is often best to discard outliers before computing the line of best fit. This is particularly true of outliers along the direction, since these points may greatly influence the result. To easily visualize the outliers, it’s helpful to cap our lines at the IQR x 1.5 (or IQR x 3).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *